CORONAVIRUS: Should North Yorkshire be subdivided in the tier system?

    Talks are being held at the highest level to determine whether North Yorkshire - England's largest county could have different levels of lockdown in some parts of the area.

    North Yorkshire County Council director of health and adult services, Richard Webb, said talks were ongoing about how any changes would be implemented:  “The feedback we are getting is that nationally Whitehall is minded to look at regional or sub-regional approaches.  However, there is no direction on that at the moment. It is for consideration as ministers and civil servants think about how they best respond to this issue and we have seen some regionalised approaches in the North East and elsewhere.

    I think the issues that are on the table that need to be considered are that if the infection rate in Scarborough is half that in parts of Craven would you apply the same rule 80 miles apart?  Equally we need to think about how we prevent an escalation in cases in somewhere where they are currently low, we need to keep an eye on hospital admission rates, they are not as high as elsewhere but that could change pretty rapidly.”

    Mr Webb said that it is not just infection rates that are used to decide if to move areas into different tiers. Hospitals admissions, the number of positive cases among people aged above 60 and other factors would be taken on board, he added.

    Dr Lincoln Sargeant, the county’s director of Public Health, said the situation in North Yorkshire was further complicated by its borders with areas of higher infections, like West Yorkshire and Teesside:  “I think that creates a challenge for people in North Yorkshire around what happens if I work or need to travel into Leeds or Teesside for example.  There is an argument around the consistency of approach and I know there has been a lot of discussion around the regional/sub-regional approach so people have clarity.  So if you are in Yorkshire and the Humber there is one approach so you don’t have to check when you move from district to district to see if things have changed.  It is an ongoing discussion and debate which is likely to find the balance between local measures and the kind of broader consistency of approach that is easier to message for people.”

    Dr Sargeant added that the infection rate in North Yorkshire continued to track the national average at the “predominant spread” of the virus in the county came from households mixing indoors.  He said the figures were “much, much lower” than what the county was seeing in April and May: “The difference we are beginning to see is that the number of infections slowly influencing the number of cases, that is people who are becoming ill and becoming hospitalised.”  He added, the county was not “in the ballpark yet” of hospital rates at the start of the pandemic but he warned:  “It is important that we maintain vigilance as that is exactly what we want to avoid, we want to keep admissions low that is why all our efforts are about keeping infection rates low and preventing that translation into cases.”

    North Yorkshire has a rate of 112 cases per 100,000 people on a seven-day average but individual districts differ greatly. Scarborough has a rate of 80 compared to Harrogate at 147.  He also revealed that 88 people were currently in hospitals in North Yorkshire, with 10 of these people in Intensive Care beds.

    More from Dales News

    On Air

    • Julian at Breakfast

      The best way to start your day in the Dales with News, Weather and Sport and Dales Music Mix.

    • Lee Moulsdale

      Weekday Mornings with the Classic Top 3 and No 1's @1

    • Keith Fletcher

      The Dales Drive Home with the very best music and conversation.

    • Rob Stevens

      The Dales Evening Show with great music and a finger on the pulse of the Dales

    • StressBusters

      Ease the troubles of the day away with late night easy listening,

    • Nic Foster

      Saturday Morning brought to life with Great Music, Loads of info on events in the Dales, Local stories from the week and the weekend edition of The Time Machine.

    • Nick Babb - Stuck In The 80s

      Two hours packed with the biggest songs from the 1980s.

    • Stuart Clarkson

      A comprehensive guide to what’s happening at the weekend, a look at the weekend's sporting action, the latest news and great tunes for your Saturday afternoon.

    Dales Weather

    • Skipton

      Light rain

      High: 11°C | Low: 6°C

    • Settle

      Light rain

      High: 10°C | Low: 6°C

    • Leyburn

      Light rain

      High: 12°C | Low: 6°C

    • Sedbergh

      Light rain

      High: 10°C | Low: 6°C

    • Kirkby Stephen

      Light rain

      High: 10°C | Low: 6°C

    Recently Played

    Dales Diary

    • Pumpkin Trail

      From 24th October to 1st November it's the Seasons Bakery Pumpkin Trail in Ingleton. Dress up and celebrate the new normal way of Halloween. Follow the map around Ingleton and find the pumpkins with letters on. Create a word and discover your Trick or Treat. The cost is £2 per person with the maximum number in any group to be no more than 6 to follow the current government guidelines. All proceeds for this event are going towards St. Mary’s Church and the Pop-Up Pantry.

      at Seasons Bakery
    • Medieval Music in the Dales

      Medieval Music in the Dales at Bolton Castle, Leyburn is the UK's only festival of medieval music and it’s online anytime this year, due to the pandemic. The festival features performances from dozens of musicians - some live online, others pre-recorded exclusively to premier at Medieval Music in the Dales. On top of that, you can enjoy a virtual tour of the amazing venue - Bolton Castle - and join in on vocal and instrumental workshops.

      at Online
    • Cave Exploring

      If you are on a staycation in the beautiful Yorkshire Dales National Park then you are in the most extensive caving area in the UK. So if you’re looking for something to do or if you live in the Dales and you fancy exploring the marvellous caves, which includes the longest cave system, one of the largest caverns, and the highest unbroken underground waterfall at Gaping Gill then head online to for more info.

      at Yorkshire Dales